: In these versions, Tyler (sometimes humorously equated to other pop-culture characters like Bakugou from My Hero Academia ) hides a massive crush on Aaron Z while trying to maintain his "cool" jock persona. Perspectives from the Fandom

The community frequently highlights the chemistry they perceive between the two characters, often focusing on their contrasting personalities—Tyler's hidden softness and Aaron Z's stoic yet supportive nature.

Common tropes and narratives found in community-created works include:

: A popular AU scenario places both the band members and Tyler at a summer camp, providing a grounded setting for their relationship to develop away from the spotlight.