It successfully blends the classic Western aesthetic with a "whodunit" detective structure.
Some mystery tropes are easy to spot if you’re a genre veteran.
At over two hours, the middle act feels stretched and repetitive.
A few subplots feel unnecessary and distract from the main tension.
Murder at Yellowstone City is a visually striking "Western Noir" that prioritizes atmosphere and performance over a fast-moving plot . While it occasionally stumbles under its own length, its stellar cast and grim tone make it a worthwhile watch for fans of slow-burn mysteries.