Where To Buy Key Lime Pie Near Me May 2026

Many locals swear they have the most genuine pie in town, supplied by the famous "Kelly’s Specialty Pies". Joe Patti's Seafood Closed524 S B St

Apple Market for authentic local "Kelly’s Specialty Pies". where to buy key lime pie near me

Known for handcrafted key lime cheesecakes that offer a richer, creamier profile. Szotski's Cheesecakes Dessert shop Closed2600 W 9 Mile Rd #6 Many locals swear they have the most genuine

Offers seasonal mini cheesecakes and slices that balance tangy lime with a sweet base. Adonna's Garden St Cafe and Bakery $10–20Cafe Closed811 W Garden St Szotski's Cheesecakes Dessert shop Closed2600 W 9 Mile

A local staple where the key lime pies are made by a local baker and kept near the "sweet finds" section. Publix Super Markets

Craft Gourmet Bakery for award-winning, small-batch versions. 🛒 Best Markets & Grab-and-Go Sometimes you just want to grab a whole pie and head home. Apple Market Supermarket Open1021 Scenic Hwy